The Unofficial Home of Shredded Chicken Sandwiches

Places that used to serve them

Old Rating	Location	Cost	Comments
	South Side Six 737 South Main Street Bowling Green, OH 43402 419/352-8639 N 41 21.885 / W 83 39.024	$2.99 (Jun 2009)	Aug 2010 - They no longer serve chicken sandwiches (but still have the Hummus). June 2009 - Thanks to Dan S. who would give it 3 hens. Comes with a side of fries for $2.99 ($1.99 on Mondays). While you are there, you can also buy the best Hummus in all of the Midwest.
	Trail Family Diner 320 Dewey Avenue Cambridge, Ohio 43725 740/432-1733 N 40 1.353 / W 81 35.886	$2.25 (Aug 2010)	2016 - They dropped them several years ago. 2010 - Way too goopy. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-8pm, closed Sun.
	Scoops 202 Lancaster Pike Circleville, Ohio 43113 740/474-9825 N 39 35.967 / W 82 55.868	Unknown	2020 - Closed. Moved to Lancaster. Feb 2012 - Thanks to Nikki B.
	Scoreboard Drive-In 804 Market Street Danville, Ohio 43014 740/599-6138 N 40 26.579 / W 82 15.633 Photograph	$3.00 (May 2017)	July 2019 - Not profitable, went out of business. May 2017 - Open Wed-Sat 11am-7pm, Sun 11am-3pm. June 2015 - Open Mon-Sat 11am-8pm, Sun 12noon-8pm, summers only through October. 2010 - Creamed chicken sandwich. The right consistency on a plain bun. It is on the corner of Market and Tough Streets.
	Eric's All American Ice Cream Factory 1912 Baltimore Street Defiance, Ohio 43512 419/784-2422 N 41 16.610 / W 84 23.572	Unknown	Nov 2008 - Burned down. Re-opened on Clinton Street in May 2009. 2008 - Thanks to Shelly K.
	Aladdin Restaurant 122 Broadway East Granville, Ohio 740/587-0253 N 40 4.085 / W 82 31.157 Photograph	$3.25 (Oct 2009)	Dec 2010 - Closed at the end of the year. Oct 2009 - Very generous portion with lots of chicken. Could use some liquid to help hold it together. 2009 - Thanks to Jim I.
	Knuckle Heads 470 South Main Street Granville, Ohio 43023 740/587-0850 N 40 03.814 / W 82 31.174	$3.95 (Oct 2017)	Sept 2022 - Boarded up. Oct 2017 - No longer reccomend this place as they now have a NO CASH policy. May 2017 - Great sandwich with a generous portion on a large sesame roll. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-9pm, closed Sunday. June 2015 - Great sandwich with a generous portion on a large roll. June 2015 - Open 11am-9pm all year. Aug 2014 - Same as last year. Oct 2013 - Still a generous portion on a large sesame roll. Lots of chicken. Good flavor and texture. May 2012 - Generous portion on a large sesame roll. A bit dry. Good chicken flavor and texture. Open daily 11am-9pm, 11am-10pm from April through October. Aug 2011 - Generous portion on an egg roll. The right amount of seasoning. Good chicken flavor and texture. Open daily 11am-9pm, 11am-10pm from April through October. Aug 2010 - Generous portion on a large sesame seed bun. Quite good. Oct 2004 - Generous portion on a sesame seed bun. Slightly tough.
	Whit's Frozen Custard 138 East Broadway Granville, Ohio 43023 740/587-3620 N 40 4.077 / W 82 31.160	$3.95 (May 2017)	Sept 2022 - Now a pretzel store. June 2015 - Standard sandwich on a plain bun. June 2015 - Open Mon-Thurs 6am-8pm, Fri 6am-8:30pm, Sat 7am-8:30pm, Sun 9am-8pm, closed 12/19-2/28. Aug 2011 - Generous portion on an egg roll. Not much seasoning. 2010 - Whit's is a chain of frozen custard stores.
	Moundbuilder's Dairy Bar 251 South 21st Street Heath, Ohio 43055 740/522-4352 N 40 02.664 / W 82 25.882 Photograph	$2.75 (July 2018)	July 2024 - Shut down for good. July 2018 - Small portion on an over-microwaved plain bun. May 2017 - Small portion on an old plain bun. June 2015 - Decent sandwich on an egg bun. Aug 2011 - Small potion on a plain bun. The bun was old. Closed in winter. Oct 2006 - Plain bun. Still not enough chicken and way too goopy. Oct 1999 - Not enough chicken.
	Dairy Queen 720 Hebron Road Heath, Ohio 43056 740/522-4004 N 40 01.941 / W 82 26.177 Photograph	$2.39 (Aug 2014)	Aug 2016 - No longer serve them. Aug 2014 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Oct 2013 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2011 - Open Sun-Thur 10:30am-10pm, Fri-Sat 10:30am-11pm. Aug 2010 - Still only $1.99 on Thursdays. Oct 2008 - Way too messy to eat by hand. Only $1.99 on Thursdays.
	Miller's Family Kitchen & Bakery 771 South 30th Street Heath, Ohio 43056 740/522-6699 N 40 1.955 / W 82 26.877	$5.99 (Oct 2013)	Oct 2013 - This is a very pricy sandwich. You can also get it with 2 sides for $8.59. We had it on toasted homemade bread, thus the high rating. Subtract one chicken if you get it on a standard bun. Aug 2011 - Excellent sandwich on a seasme seed bun. Very generous portion. Also available as a special for $7.99 that includes two sides. Their shredded chicken sandwiches are not on the menu but are a very popular item. They usually have them but call ahead to make sure. They are located in the food court of the Indian Mound Mall. Use entrance "C"" on the north side by the movie theaters. Note: This is the re-incarnation of Miller's Essenplatz that used to be in Newark. Open all year Mon-Sat 10am-9pm, closed Sunday.
	Yummy's Dairy Creem 10960 Hebron Road Hebron (Buckeye Lake) Ohio 43025 740/929-2342 N 39 56.250 / W 82 28.797	$2.00 (Jul 2002)	Oct 2006 - Out of business
	Twisters 551 West Coshocton Street Johnstown, Ohio 43031 740/967-5300 N 40 08.911 / W 82 41.876	$2.00 (Oct 2006)	2010 - Location now occupied by Whit's Frozen Custard. 2006 - Closed December - February. Walk in or drive through.
	Happy Penguin Cafe 1531 Granville Pike Lancaster, OH 43130 740/654-2242 N 39 44.264 / W 82 35.333	$2.99 (Feb 2012)	2020 - Closed. 2010 - Thanks to Wennie W. Open Mon-Fri 7am-6pm, Fri 7am-8pm, Sat 7am-2pm, closed Sunday. Shredded chicken is their most popular sandwich.
	The Hungry Heifer Cafe 11 W Main Street Lexington, Ohio 44904 419/651-5467 N 40 40.725 / W 82 35.003	Unknown	2010 - Out of business 2009 - Thanks to Ben H.
	Zig's Dairy Stand 487 Grace Street Mansfield, Ohio 44905 419/524-7700 N 40 46.218 / W 82 29.836	$2.50 (May 2011)	May 2011 - Thanks to Lisa S. They also have the best milkshakes in the area.
	Farmhouse Ice Cream Parlor 123 East 5th Street Marysville, Ohio 43040 937/738-7513 N 40 14.180 / W 83 21.961	$2.99 (Oct 2010)	Oct 2010 - Thanks to Rob H. Open all year 11:30am-9pm. April 2014 - Whit's Frozen Custard took over the location.
	Barb's Country Diner 201 Columbus Road Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050 740/397-3833 N 40 22.698 / W 82 29.863	$2.79 (Aug 2011)	July 2024 - Gone. Aug 2011 - Real chicken on a plain toasted bun. Well seasoned. Not goopy. Open all year Mon-Fri 7am-7pm, Sat 7am-2pm, closed Sunday.
	The Dairy 300 Wooster Road Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050 740/393-3156 N 40 24.186 / W 82 28.802	$2.50 (May 2017)	July 2018 - Changed hands and is now the Round Hill Dairy. All ice cream and no sandwiches. May 2017 - Open all year Tue-Sun 11am-6pm, closed Monday. Aug 2014 - You can get a sandwich, french fries, and a drink for $5.00. They also have good ice cream with generous scoups at very very reasonable prices. Oct 2013 - Very goopy on a plain bun. Didn't much care for the taste. Oct 2013- Open all year. Sun-Wed 11am-10pm, Thur-Sat 11am-1pm in the summer. Every day 11am-8pm in the winter.
	R&M's Southside Diner 620 South Main Street Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050 740/392-1282 N 40 23.058 / W 82 29.163 Photograph	$4.49 (May 2017)	Sept 2022 - Still in business. They just dropped shredded chicken sandwiches from their menu. Great old 50's diner. Lots of comfort food and good values. May 2017 - Sandwich comes with chips. Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.99. Aug 2016 - Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.49. June 2015 - Huge portion on a plainbun. Good flavor but messy. Comes in chice f bun and with a bag of chips. Open all year. Mon-Sat 6am-8pm, Sun 8am-3pm. July 2013 - Choice of white, wheat, rye, or sourdough bun. Oct 2006 - Plain bun. Lots of chicken. Good consistency. Price includes fries. Slightly cheaper without fries.
	Tiffany's Ice Cream Parlor 1 N. 3rd Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/349-7566 N 40 03.453 / W 82 24.149	$2.20 (Aug 2005)	Oct 2007 - Out of business Closed during the winter. Oct 2004 - Plain bun, nice sandwich
	Miller's Essenplatz 1058 East Main Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/345-7900 N 40 3.673 / W 82 21.709 Photograph	$6.99 (Aug 2010)	Jan 29, 2011 - Last day of business. Oct 2009 - Same good sandwich as usual. Open Mon-Thur 11am-8pm, Fri-Sat 11am-9pm, closed Sun. Oct 2006 - Very good. Open all year. Aug 2005 - Good as ever. Oct 2004 - This time it was still good. Recommend the chicken and noodle side dish. Oct 1999 - The best sandwich, period. Served on toasted home made bread with a pickle slice and one side dish of your choice. There are about 20 side dishes to choose from.
	Holly's Dairy Bar 182 National Drive Newark, Ohio 43055 740/323-1330 N 40 02.872 / W 82 24.191 Photograph	$2.50 (Oct 2013)	Oct 31, 2013 - Last day of business. (Changing hands.) Oct 2013 - Still a good tasting sandwich but a bit goopy. May 2012 - Good tasting sandwich but a bit goopy. Aug 2011 - Good sandwich but a bit goopy. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-9pm. Oct 2009 - Good sandwich, a cut above. Aug 2008 - Good flavor and good portion on a plain bun but too goopy. Oct 2007 - Good flavor. Generous portion on a plain bun.
	Duchess Shoppee (BP) 1175 West Church Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/344-8800 N 40 3.476 / W 82 26.810 Photograph	$1.89 (Aug 2010)	This is a gas station with a do it yourself sandwich.
	Dairy Queen 1775 North 21st Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/366-6210 N 40 05.766 / W 82 25.584 Photograph	$2.39 (July 2013)	Feb 2016 - They were a good seller but they stopped selling them. July 2013 - Sesame seed bun. Some 'foreign' stuff in the chicken. Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2011 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2008 - Still too messy. Some 'foreign' stuff in the chicken. Oct 2006 - Really messy but good taste. Lots of chicken.
	Debbie's Ice Cream 182 W. National Drive Newark, Ohio 43055 740/323-1330 N 40 02.872 / W 82 24.191	$2.19 (Aug 2014)	May 2015 - Out of business. Replaced by Don & Sue's Pizza. April 2014 - Open under new management. (Was Holly's Dairy Bar.) Two sandwiches for $3.50 on Thursdays. Open Tue-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-10pm, closed Mon.
	Franks and Sammies 34 S. 3rd Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/915-1812 N 40 3.400 / W 82 24.125	$3.95 (July 2020)	Sept 2022 - Out of business. Sign on the door says the bar next door has their food. July 2020 - Thanks to XXX It's called the "Cotton Eye Joe" Open all year Mon-Tue 10:30am-3pm, Wed-Thur 10:30am-6:30pm, Fri 10:30am-8pm, Sat 11am-6pm, closed Sun.
	Dairy Queen 6563 E. Livingston Ave. Reynoldsburg, Ohio 43068 614/864-7617 N 39 56.582 / W 82 49.234	$2.69 (Oct 2004)	Aug 2008 - Out of business Oct 2004 - Good chicken taste
	Cones 'N Concoctions 1500 East Broad Street Reynoldsburg, OH 43068 614/866-6673 N 39 59.293 / W 82 46.034 Photograph	$2.75 (Aug 2011)	2010 - Generous properly seasoned portion with good consistency on a plain bun. Open Mon-Thur 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-9pm, summer only through October.
	The Loft 7467 Mt. Vernon Road St. Louisville, Ohio 43071 740/745-2141 N 40 9.734 / W 82 25.490	$2.00 (Aug 2010)	--- This is a bar --- Oct 2013 - Burned down. Aug 2010 - Large portion on a slightly smaller bun. Not canned chicken.
	Dari Shack 28 West Columbus Road Utica, Ohio 43080 740/892-3999 N 40 13.774 / W 82 27.178 Photograph	$2.60 (Aug 2010)	Aug 2011 - Out of business. Oct 2009 - Good as ever. This thing is still a full meal. Aug 2008 - Good flavor. Generous portion on a large sesame seed bun. On south side of SR 62 just 100' west of SR 13. Open all year, Mon-Sat 11am-9pm, Sun 12noon-9pm. Oct 2006 - Good flavor. Large sesame seed bun.
	Premium Concoctions 115 S. Main Street Utica, Ohio 43080 740/759-7078 N 40 13.927 / W 82 27.179	$3.75 (May 2017)	July 2018 - Closed. Building for sale. May 2017 - They are $2.00 on Mondays. Aug 2016 - Basic sandwich on a plain bun. Open Mon-Sat 11:30am-8:30pm, Sun 12noon-8pm.
	Tom's Ice Cream Bowl 532 McIntire Avenue Zanesville, Ohio 43701 740/452-5267 N 39 56.883 / W 82 0.662	$3.30 (June 2015)	Aug 2016 - New menu and they have dropped them. June 2015 - Generous portion on a plain bun. May 2012 - Generous portion on a plain bun with an unusual flavor. Oct 2007 - Just added chicken sandwiches this year. Plain bun with lettuce. Spiced a bit different from others.

Top of page