 |
The Unofficial Home of Shredded Chicken Sandwiches |  |
|
The Unofficial Home of Shredded Chicken Sandwiches | |
| Old Rating | Location | Cost | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
 | South Side Six 737 South Main Street Bowling Green, OH 43402 419/352-8639 | $2.99 | Aug 2010 -
They no longer serve chicken sandwiches (but still have the Hummus). June 2009 - Thanks to Dan S. who would give it 3 hens. Comes with a side of fries for $2.99 ($1.99 on Mondays). While you are there, you can also buy the best Hummus in all of the Midwest. |
 | Trail Family Diner 320 Dewey Avenue Cambridge, Ohio 43725 740/432-1733 | $2.25 (Aug 2010) | 2016 - They dropped them
several years ago. 2010 - Way too goopy. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-8pm, closed Sun. |
| Scoops 202 Lancaster Pike Circleville, Ohio 43113 740/474-9825 |
Unknown | 2020 - Closed. Moved to Lancaster. Feb 2012 - Thanks to Nikki B. |
 | Scoreboard Drive-In 804 Market Street Danville, Ohio 43014 740/599-6138 Photograph | $3.00 (May 2017) | July 2019
- Not profitable, went out of business. May 2017 - Open Wed-Sat 11am-7pm, Sun 11am-3pm. June 2015 - Open Mon-Sat 11am-8pm, Sun 12noon-8pm, summers only through October. 2010 - Creamed chicken sandwich. The right consistency on a plain bun. It is on the corner of Market and Tough Streets. |
| Eric's All American Ice Cream
Factory 1912 Baltimore Street Defiance, Ohio 43512 419/784-2422 | Unknown | Nov 2008 -
Burned down. Re-opened on Clinton Street in May 2009. 2008 - Thanks to Shelly K. |
 | Aladdin Restaurant 122 Broadway East Granville, Ohio 740/587-0253 Photograph | $3.25 (Oct 2009) | Dec 2010 - Closed at the end of the year. Oct 2009 - Very generous portion with lots of chicken. Could use some liquid to help hold it together. 2009 - Thanks to Jim I. |
| Knuckle Heads 470 South Main Street Granville, Ohio 43023 740/587-0850 | $3.95 (Oct 2017) | Sept 2022 - Boarded up. Oct 2017 - No longer reccomend this place as they now have a NO CASH policy. May 2017 - Great sandwich with a generous portion on a large sesame roll. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-9pm, closed Sunday. June 2015 - Great sandwich with a generous portion on a large roll. June 2015 - Open 11am-9pm all year. Aug 2014 - Same as last year. Oct 2013 - Still a generous portion on a large sesame roll. Lots of chicken. Good flavor and texture. May 2012 - Generous portion on a large sesame roll. A bit dry. Good chicken flavor and texture. Open daily 11am-9pm, 11am-10pm from April through October. Aug 2011 - Generous portion on an egg roll. The right amount of seasoning. Good chicken flavor and texture. Open daily 11am-9pm, 11am-10pm from April through October. Aug 2010 - Generous portion on a large sesame seed bun. Quite good. Oct 2004 - Generous portion on a sesame seed bun. Slightly tough. |
 | Whit's Frozen Custard 138 East Broadway Granville, Ohio 43023 740/587-3620 | $3.95 (May 2017) | Sept 2022 - Now a pretzel
store. June 2015 - Standard sandwich on a plain bun. June 2015 - Open Mon-Thurs 6am-8pm, Fri 6am-8:30pm, Sat 7am-8:30pm, Sun 9am-8pm, closed 12/19-2/28. Aug 2011 - Generous portion on an egg roll. Not much seasoning. 2010 - Whit's is a chain of frozen custard stores. |
 | Dairy Queen 720 Hebron Road Heath, Ohio 43056 740/522-4004 Photograph | $2.39 (Aug 2014) | Aug 2016 -
No longer serve them. Aug 2014 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Oct 2013 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2011 - Open Sun-Thur 10:30am-10pm, Fri-Sat 10:30am-11pm. Aug 2010 - Still only $1.99 on Thursdays. Oct 2008 - Way too messy to eat by hand. Only $1.99 on Thursdays. |
| Yummy's Dairy Creem 10960 Hebron Road Hebron (Buckeye Lake) Ohio 43025 740/929-2342 N 39 56.250 / W 82 28.797 | $2.00 (Jul 2002) | Oct 2006 - Out of business |
| Twisters 551 West Coshocton Street Johnstown, Ohio 43031 740/967-5300 |
$2.00 (Oct 2006) | 2010 - Location now occupied by Whit's Frozen
Custard. 2006 - Closed December - February. Walk in or drive through. |
| Happy
Penguin Cafe 1531 Granville Pike Lancaster, OH 43130 740/654-2242 | $2.99 (Feb 2012) | 2020 - Closed. 2010 - Thanks to Wennie W. Open Mon-Fri 7am-6pm, Fri 7am-8pm, Sat 7am-2pm, closed Sunday. Shredded chicken is their most popular sandwich. |
| The Hungry Heifer Cafe 11 W Main Street Lexington, Ohio 44904 419/651-5467 |
Unknown | 2010 - Out of business 2009 - Thanks to Ben H. |
| Zig's Dairy Stand 487 Grace Street Mansfield, Ohio 44905 419/524-7700 | $2.50 (May 2011) | May 2011 - Thanks to Lisa S. They also have the best milkshakes in the area. |
| Farmhouse Ice Cream
Parlor 123 East 5th Street Marysville, Ohio 43040 937/738-7513 | $2.99 (Oct 2010) | Oct 2010 - Thanks to Rob H. Open all year 11:30am-9pm. April 2014 - Whit's Frozen Custard took over the location. |
| The
Dairy 300 Wooster Road Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050 740/393-3156 | $2.50 (May 2017) |
July 2018 - Changed hands and is now the Round Hill Dairy. All ice cream and
no sandwiches. May 2017 - Open all year Tue-Sun 11am-6pm, closed Monday. Aug 2014 - You can get a sandwich, french fries, and a drink for $5.00. They also have good ice cream with generous scoups at very very reasonable prices. Oct 2013 - Very goopy on a plain bun. Didn't much care for the taste. Oct 2013- Open all year. Sun-Wed 11am-10pm, Thur-Sat 11am-1pm in the summer. Every day 11am-8pm in the winter. |
| R&M's Southside Diner 620 South Main Street Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050 740/392-1282 Photograph | $4.49 (May 2017) | Sept 2022
- Still in business. They just dropped shredded chicken sandwiches from their
menu. Great old 50's diner. Lots of comfort food and good values. May 2017 - Sandwich comes with chips. Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.99. Aug 2016 - Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.49. June 2015 - Huge portion on a plainbun. Good flavor but messy. Comes in chice f bun and with a bag of chips. Open all year. Mon-Sat 6am-8pm, Sun 8am-3pm. July 2013 - Choice of white, wheat, rye, or sourdough bun. Oct 2006 - Plain bun. Lots of chicken. Good consistency. Price includes fries. Slightly cheaper without fries. |
| Tiffany's Ice Cream Parlor 1 N. 3rd Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/349-7566 N 40 03.453 / W 82 24.149 | $2.20 | Oct 2007 - Out of
business Closed during the winter. Oct 2004 - Plain bun, nice sandwich |
| Miller's
Essenplatz 1058 East Main Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/345-7900 Photograph | $6.99 (Aug 2010) | Jan 29, 2011 - Last day of business. Oct 2009 - Same good sandwich as usual. Open Mon-Thur 11am-8pm, Fri-Sat 11am-9pm, closed Sun. Oct 2006 - Very good. Open all year. Aug 2005 - Good as ever. Oct 2004 - This time it was still good. Recommend the chicken and noodle side dish. Oct 1999 - The best sandwich, period. Served on toasted home made bread with a pickle slice and one side dish of your choice. There are about 20 side dishes to choose from. |
| Holly's Dairy Bar 182 National Drive Newark, Ohio 43055 740/323-1330 Photograph | $2.50 (Oct 2013) | Oct 31,
2013 - Last day of business. (Changing hands.) Oct 2013 - Still a good tasting sandwich but a bit goopy. May 2012 - Good tasting sandwich but a bit goopy. Aug 2011 - Good sandwich but a bit goopy. Open all year Mon-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-9pm. Oct 2009 - Good sandwich, a cut above. Aug 2008 - Good flavor and good portion on a plain bun but too goopy. Oct 2007 - Good flavor. Generous portion on a plain bun. |
| Duchess Shoppee (BP) 1175 West Church Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/344-8800 Photograph |
$1.89 (Aug 2010) | This is a gas station with a do it yourself sandwich. |
| Dairy Queen 1775 North 21st Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/366-6210 Photograph | $2.39 (July 2013) | Feb 2016
- They were a good seller but they stopped selling them. July 2013 - Sesame seed bun. Some 'foreign' stuff in the chicken. Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2011 - Only $1.99 on Thursdays. Aug 2008 - Still too messy. Some 'foreign' stuff in the chicken. Oct 2006 - Really messy but good taste. Lots of chicken. |
| Debbie's Ice Cream 182 W. National Drive Newark, Ohio 43055 740/323-1330 |
$2.19 (Aug 2014) | May 2015 - Out of business. Replaced by Don
& Sue's Pizza. April 2014 - Open under new management. (Was Holly's Dairy Bar.) Two sandwiches for $3.50 on Thursdays. Open Tue-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-10pm, closed Mon. |
| Franks and Sammies 34 S. 3rd Street Newark, Ohio 43055 740/915-1812 | $3.95 (July 2020) | Sept 2022 - Out of
business. Sign on the door says the bar next door has their food. July 2020 - Thanks to XXX It's called the "Cotton Eye Joe" Open all year Mon-Tue 10:30am-3pm, Wed-Thur 10:30am-6:30pm, Fri 10:30am-8pm, Sat 11am-6pm, closed Sun. |
| Dairy Queen 6563 E. Livingston Ave. Reynoldsburg, Ohio 43068 614/864-7617 N 39 56.582 / W 82 49.234 |
$2.69 (Oct 2004) | Aug 2008 - Out of business Oct 2004 - Good chicken taste |
| Cones 'N Concoctions 1500 East Broad Street Reynoldsburg, OH 43068 614/866-6673 Photograph | $2.75 (Aug 2011) | 2010 -
Generous properly seasoned portion with good consistency on a plain bun. Open Mon-Thur 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 12noon-9pm, summer only through October. |
| The Loft 7467 Mt. Vernon Road St. Louisville, Ohio 43071 740/745-2141 |
$2.00 (Aug 2010) | --- This is a bar --- Oct 2013 - Burned down. Aug 2010 - Large portion on a slightly smaller bun. Not canned chicken. |
| Dari Shack 28 West Columbus Road Utica, Ohio 43080 740/892-3999 Photograph | $2.60 (Aug 2010) | Aug 2011 -
Out of business. Oct 2009 - Good as ever. This thing is still a full meal. Aug 2008 - Good flavor. Generous portion on a large sesame seed bun. On south side of SR 62 just 100' west of SR 13. Open all year, Mon-Sat 11am-9pm, Sun 12noon-9pm. Oct 2006 - Good flavor. Large sesame seed bun. |
| Premium Concoctions 115 S. Main Street Utica, Ohio 43080 740/759-7078 | $3.75 (May 2017) | July 2018 - Closed.
Building for sale. May 2017 - They are $2.00 on Mondays. Aug 2016 - Basic sandwich on a plain bun. Open Mon-Sat 11:30am-8:30pm, Sun 12noon-8pm. |
| Tom's Ice
Cream Bowl 532 McIntire Avenue Zanesville, Ohio 43701 740/452-5267 | $3.30 (June 2015) | Aug 2016 - New menu and they have dropped them. June 2015 - Generous portion on a plain bun. May 2012 - Generous portion on a plain bun with an unusual flavor. Oct 2007 - Just added chicken sandwiches this year. Plain bun with lettuce. Spiced a bit different from others. |
