chicken The Unofficial Home of
Shredded
Chicken Sandwiches
chicken

Home page Restaurants Drive-ins Recipes Your
comments Contact us


Restaurants that serve them

Clyde, OH (1)
Findlay, OH (1)
Galion, OH (1)
Heath, OH (2)
Hebron, OH (1)
Kenton, OH (1)
Lima, OH (5)
Mansfield, OH (1)
Mt. Vernon, OH (2)
Newark, OH (3)
North Canton, OH (1)
Port Clinton, OH (1)
Sidney, OH (1)
Utica, OH (1)
West Lafayette, OH (1)


Rating Location
Cost Comments

Not yet rated Cahill Cafe
115 S. Main Street
Clyde, Ohio 43410
419/765-9146
N 41 18.286 / W 82 58.511
$4.50
(July 2016)
July 2016 - Sold and will reopen under the name Main Street Cafe.
July 2016 - Thanks to Peni G.
Sept 2014 - Thanks to Paul G.
Served on your choice of bread with chips and pickle or vegetables and homemade dill dip.
Open all year Mon-Fri 7am-2pm, Sat 8am-1pm, closed Sunday.

Not yet rated Shady Grove Golf Course and Restaurant
15733 East US Route 224
Findlay, Ohio 45840
419/422-7078
N 41 3.449 / W 83 34.707
Unknown Dec 2013 - Thanks to Kent E.
Open daily 11am-9pm.

Not yet rated Taylor's
146 Portland Way North
Galion, Ohio 44833
419/468-2833
N 40 44.081 / W 82 48.136
Unknown Mar 2011 - Thanks to Zena.


Heath City School District Cafeterias

Heath, Ohio 43056


Oct 2008 - Ok, this isn't really a restaurant. I just throught it was curious that a school system would regularly make shredded chicken sandwiches available to their students.
4 1/2 chickens Miller's Family Kitchen & Bakery
771 South 30th Street
Heath, Ohio 43056
740/522-6699
N 40 1.955 / W 82 26.877
$5.99
(Oct 2013)
Oct 2013 - This is a very pricy sandwich. You can also get it with 2 sides for $8.59. We had it on toasted homemade bread, thus the high rating. Subtract one chicken if you get it on a standard bun.
Aug 2011 - Excellent sandwich on a seasme seed bun. Very generous portion. Also available as a special for $7.99 that includes two sides. Their shredded chicken sandwiches are not on the menu but are a very popular item. They usually have them but call ahead to make sure.
They are located in the food court of the Indian Mound Mall. Use entrance "C"" on the north side by the movie theaters.
Note: This is the re-incarnation of Miller's Essenplatz that used to be in Newark.
Open all year Mon-Sat 10am-9pm, closed Sunday.

4 chickens Clay's Cafe
808 W. Main Street
Hebron, Ohio
740/929-2529
N 39 57.645 / W 82 29.838
Photograph
$2.79
(May 2017)
Aug 2014 - Same as last year. The stromboli is to die for.
Oct 2013 - Same as last year but $1 less. They also have excellent stromboli.
May 2012 - Same as last year but $1 more.
Aug 2011 - Same as last year.
Open all year, Mon-Sat 10am-10pm, closed Sunday.
Aug 2010 - Excellent taste, chunks of chicken, toasted sesame seed bun. Either sit-down or to go.
Oct 2009 - Really good. Upgraded rating.
Oct 2006 - Good toasted sesame seed bun.

Not yet rated Thomas Family Tavern
801 Steiner Avenue
Kenton, Ohio 43326
419/674-4581
N 40 38.240 / W 83 36.505
About $4.00
(Apr 2012)
Apr 2012 - Thanks to Jeannie R.

Not yet rated Happy Daz
810 West North Street
Lima, Ohio 45801
419/227-3663
N 40 44.573 / W 84 7.027
$2.69
(May 2009)
2008 - Thanks to Dawn T.
Chain of five restaurants in Lima, OH.
Not yet
rated Happy Daz
802 South Cable Road
Lima, Ohio 45805
419/227-3663
N 40 43.813 / W 84 8.814
$2.69
(May 2009)
2008 - Thanks to Dawn T.
Chain of five restaurants in Lima, OH.
Not yet
rated Happy Daz
1064 Bellefontaine Avenue
Lima, Ohio 45804
419/227-3663
N 40 44.037 / W 84 5.122
$2.69
(May 2009)
2008 - Thanks to Dawn T.
Chain of five restaurants in Lima, OH.
Not yet
rated Happy Daz
4557 Elida Road
Lima, Ohio 45807-
419/227-3663
N 40 46.859 / W 84 11.259
$2.69
(May 2009)
2008 - Thanks to Dawn T.
Chain of five restaurants in Lima, OH.
Not yet
rated Happy Daz
2025 North West Street
Lima, Ohio 45801
419/227-3663
N 40 46.159 / W 84 6.531
$2.69
(May 2009)
2008 - Thanks to Dawn T.
Chain of five restaurants in Lima, OH.

Not yet rated Ed Picken's Cafe on Main
28 North Main Street
Mansfield, Ohio 44902
419/522-7699
N 40 45.548 / W 82 30.929
$4.50
(May 2014)
May 2014 - Thanks to Sam I.
Served on a wheat Kaiser roll.
Open all year Mon-Fri 10am-3pm, closed Sat and Sun.

3
chickens R&M's Southside Diner
620 South Main Street
Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050
740/392-1282
N 40 23.058 / W 82 29.163
Photograph
$4.49
(May 2017)
Great old 50's diner. Lots of comfort food and good values.
May 2017 - Sandwich comes with chips. Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.99.
Aug 2016 - Order on the lunch express menu and also get a side and drink for $6.49.
June 2015 - Huge portion on a plainbun. Good flavor but messy. Comes in chice f bun and with a bag of chips.
Open all year. Mon-Sat 6am-8pm, Sun 8am-3pm.
July 2013 - Choice of white, wheat, rye, or sourdough bun.
Oct 2006 - Plain bun. Lots of chicken. Good consistency. Price includes fries. Slightly cheaper without fries.
4 1/2 chickens Barb's Country Diner
201 Columbus Road
Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050
740/397-3833
N 40 22.698 / W 82 29.863
$2.79
(Aug 2011)
Aug 2011 - Real chicken on a plain toasted bun. Well seasoned. Not goopy.
Open all year Mon-Fri 7am-7pm, Sat 7am-2pm, closed Sunday.

Not yet rated Inverness Bar
63 South 4th Street
Newark, Ohio 43055
Unknown
N 40 3.476 / W 82 26.810
Photograph
$1.75
(Aug 2010)
--- This is a bar, absolutely no children ---
4
chickens Burning Tree Golf Course
4600 Ridgely Tract Road
Newark, Ohio 43056
740/522-3464
N 39 58.910 / W 82 27.178
$2.50
(May 2012)
May 2012 - A good portion on a plain bun. Good chicken flavor, chunks of chicken, and not too goopy.
Aug 2011 - Very generous portion on a plain egg roll. Good chicken flavor and not too goopy.
3 chickens The Colonial Tavern
1012 Mount Vernon Road
Newark, Ohio 43055
740/366-5040
N 40 5.069 / W 82 25.057
Photograph
$2.95
(July 2016)
--- This is a bar ---
July 2016 - Thanks to Dave B. for finding this place.
July 2016 - Standard size sandwich with a slightly differet taste.
July 2016 - Open all year Mon-Sat 6am-midnight, closed Sunday.

Not yet
rated Eadies Fish House
6616 Wise Avenue NW
North Canton, Ohio 44720
330/494-4000
N 40 52.699 / W 81 25.287
$4.99
(Jul 2013)
Jul 2013 - Thanks to Tara U.

Not yet rated Cross's Gateway Restaurant
3929 East Harbor Road
Port Clinton, Ohio 43452
419/732-3714
N 41 31.454 / W 82 51.500
$3.20
(2014)
Feb 2015 - Thanks to Anna H.

Not yet rated Smok'n Jo's BBQ
1951 West Michigan Street
Sidney, Ohio 45365
937/710-4076
N 40 17.269 / W 84 11.011
$6.19
(Jul 2013)
Jul 2013 - Thanks to Amy F.
Open Sun-Thurs 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat 11am-10pn.

3 chickens Ye Olde Mill
11324 Mt. Vernon Rd.
Utica, Ohio 43080
800/589-5000
N 40 12.887 / W 82 26.507
Photograph
$4.99
(Oct 2013)
June 2015 - Not serving them. Some years they have them, some years they don't.
Oct 2013 - Serving them again.
Aug 2011 - Not serving chicken sandwiches this year. Some years they ahve then, some they don't. Maybe next year?
Oct 2009 - Serving them again as a special item. They may or may not have them when you get there.
Aug 2008 - No longer serving chicken sandwiches.
Open May through October
Oct 2006 - Plain bun. Lots of chicken, messy, better with a fork. Comes with a pickle slice and a bag of chips but is over priced.

Not yet rated Hickory Flat Golf Course
54188 Township Road 155
West Lafayette, Ohio 43845
740/545-7796
N 40 15.271 / W 81 44.656
Unknown May 2012 - Thanks to Dan B.

Top of page


The rating system

5 chickens "The Best"
4 chickens Near perfection
3 chickens Average
2 chickens You might be disappointed
1 chicken Still a lot better than a hamburger
Not yet rated Not yet rated


Started Summer of 1999, last updated Spring of 2017.
Made on Macintosh.